
Two mistakes I made on holiday
Saturday 23 November 2024, 14:41 by Elvira Smit | 2,726 views | 5 commentsThis article was translated from Dutch with the help of AI. Read the original.
I was recently in Spain. Two striking things happened there: I took just 32 photos in two weeks. And I used ChatGPT during a visit to a cathedral. Here is my critical reflection on both.
1. I took too few photos
I have a difficult relationship with taking photos on holiday. Which images ‘capture’ the holiday and will still be enjoyable at home? And what do my images add to the idiotic stream of images that already exists of every place I visit?
Anyway, this holiday I once again found myself being contemplative about photography in general and my own behaviour in particular. I really did not feel like taking photos at all. My behaviour was an anti-movement against the photographing human.
Take the Alhambra in Granada. I was constantly bumping into groups of tourists who viewed the world through the tiny screen on their phones:

Absolutely no one in the group above is looking at anything directly. Their appreciation takes place through a screen.
Strange, really.
Psychologist Kahneman divides the human mind into two parts: the experiencing self and the remembering self. With the arrival of the camera, and later the smartphone, our experiencing self has shrunk considerably.
And that is why I did not feel like taking photos. I wanted to experience the moment and ignore my remembering self. I only partly succeeded. A persistent little voice kept nagging that it would be a real shame not to have a photo of this place later.
2. I used ChatGPT in a cathedral
The next day I visited Granada Cathedral. An audio tour was included, which I switched off after three minutes. It was a bone-dry story full of unnecessary superlatives.
I sat down on a church pew, where my thoughts wandered to a book I was reading about AI (this one). Then I thought that perhaps ChatGPT could entertain me in that cathedral.
So I typed:
“Give me 5 things to look for in Granada Cathedral. I will let you know as soon as I have found something, so make sure you give me more information about what I have found.”
And sure enough, I could go looking for the All-Seeing Eye, which was supposedly incorporated somewhere into the cathedral ceiling. I could not find the eye, so I asked for clues. I got them: I had to look specifically at this part of the ceiling:

I still could not see anything.
After about 10 minutes, I gave up. I asked ChatGPT for the exact location of the eye. The answer:
“Sorry, my request was not meant literally. The All-Seeing Eye is symbolic and therefore cannot be found in the cathedral.”
Great. I felt cheated, but in the meantime I had looked at the entire cathedral ceiling in minute detail. As the experiencing self. And the remembering self can still draw on it too.
I still need to work on the prompts, but reaching for ChatGPT instead of my camera is something I will do more often. Just like taking fewer photos on holiday. In short, two things that initially felt like ‘mistakes’ turned out to be particularly worthwhile.

About the author
Ik heb een eigen fotografieblog, Kronkeling. Daar schrijf ik om de week twee artikelen. Over hoe je je blik kunt scherpen, je creativiteit kunt aanwakkeren, en over fotografen die mij inspireren. Geen technische zaken, wél over hoe je leert kijken. En dat blijkt nog een hele klus. Een mooi startpunt zijn de Kronkeltips, die vind je hier.
You might also like
-
Smartphone photography and travelby Nando Harmsen
-
An Ode to Holiday Snapshotsby Michiel Heijmans
-
A tripod for your smartphoneby Nando Harmsen
-
Locations on holiday and day tripsby Nando Harmsen
5 comments
-
Maritza wrote on Sunday 24 November 2024 at 07:09 | replyHaha I totally feel you! I often walk the route twice. First to look around and then to take photos. But I also notice that I come back with fewer and fewer photos.
Translated from Dutch. -

Elvira Smit
wrote on Monday 25 November 2024 at 10:51
| reply
@Maritza: Good tip to walk the route twice! I’m going to try that sometime too
Translated from Dutch.
-
r0bert wrote on Monday 25 November 2024 at 13:16 | replyThere are studies claiming that taking photographs actually intensifies the experience during a holiday trip. Researchers from Yale, for example, sent a test group on a bus tour through Philadelphia, half of whom took photos and the other half did not take photographs. Eye tracking showed that the group taking photographs experienced the trip more consciously through positive visual stimuli. The photographers also looked back on the trip with more pleasure afterwards than their non-photographing fellow travelers.
Translated from Dutch.
(The Yale researchers also established the opposite: people who create images of something unpleasant, such as a traffic accident, experience the event more intensely and retain a negative feeling about it for longer). -

Elvira Smit
wrote on Monday 25 November 2024 at 13:28
| reply
@R0bert: what a nice addition. I once read about that study too. If I remember correctly, the researchers also found that when people took photos with the aim of sharing them, there was no positive effect. And there was when the photo was taken solely for personal use.
Translated from Dutch.
Nice to think about and ask yourself what you get the most pleasure from!
-
Ruud wrote on Tuesday 26 November 2024 at 14:53 | replyLast spring we made a lovely tour through Italy. It is indeed and remains a struggle. What do you photograph and what not. When I photograph with my camera, I of course want to make the "perfect" picture. That takes time and you don't want to inconvenience your travelling partner by spending endless amounts of time on it. Even if it is just waiting until those hordes of tourists have left the frame. But sometimes you can get the best of both worlds.
Translated from Dutch.
We were in the Basilica of Saint Francis in Assisi. Everything there is to see has been perfectly captured in stacks of books. No need to do that yourself all over again. So, the camera didn't come along. But, suddenly, out of nowhere, a magnificent song was started there by, as it turned out later, a group of students from California. This moved me and I wanted to hold on to the moment. So I took out my phone and took photos (snapshots). From a photographic point of view, they were unsharp pictures with visitors disturbing the image. But, what I wanted to hold on to had succeeded. So much so that I recently used one of those photos in a presentation about music and youth.
Have your say
Please note: Articles older than a week can only be commented on by signed-in visitors.Would you still like to comment? sign in or create a free account.
Become a better photographer every week
A practical photography tip in your inbox every week.
39,219 photography enthusiasts already receive the tips! More about the weekly mail. Or keep up to date via
Facebook.

Elja Trum



